Insights

Why is profit falling when sales are growing?

Rising revenue with flat or falling profit is one of the most common problems a growing business faces. It nearly always comes from one of five causes, and each can be tested with data you already have.

When sales grow and profit does not, the instinct is to cut costs. That is often the wrong first move, because the profit has usually been lost somewhere between the price list and the bank account, not in the expense lines. Work through the five causes below in order.

1. Growth is coming from lower-margin sales

New revenue rarely carries the same margin as old revenue. Growth often comes from larger customers who negotiate harder, new products priced low to enter a market, or channels that take a bigger cut. The blended margin falls even though no single price changed.

How to test it. Compare gross margin by customer and by product for this year and last. If the mix has moved towards the lower-margin lines, you have found the cause. This is the starting point of a customer and product profitability analysis.

2. Discounts are rising faster than sales

A sales team chasing a volume target uses the tool it has, which is price. Discounts, free extras and extended schemes rarely appear as their own line in the P&L. They are netted off revenue, so nobody watches them grow.

How to test it. Add up discounts, rebates and credit notes as a percentage of gross sales, month by month. A rising line is revenue leakage, and it can usually be closed without raising a single list price.

3. Costs went up and prices did not

Input costs, wages and freight move every year. Price lists and long contracts often stand still, especially where an escalation clause exists and nobody applies it.

How to test it. List your twenty largest customers or contracts with the date of the last price change beside each. Anything older than your last cost increase is margin you are giving away.

4. The cost of serving customers is growing unseen

More customers bring more deliveries, more small orders, more support calls and more credit. These costs sit in overheads, so they look fixed, yet they grow with every account you add. A customer with a healthy gross margin can lose money once the effort of serving it is counted.

How to test it. Set orders, deliveries and overdue days per customer beside the margin each one earns. The accounts that are high on effort and low on margin are where profit is going.

5. Overheads were sized for a different margin

Hiring and adding capacity ahead of growth is normal. It becomes a problem when the growth arrives at a lower margin than planned, because the overhead was justified on the old one.

How to test it. Track overheads as a percentage of gross profit, not of revenue, over three years. Revenue can flatter this ratio; gross profit cannot.

Where to start

Find out which cause is at work before you act, because the fixes differ. A shift in mix calls for repricing or redirecting sales effort. Rising discounts call for approval rules. Stale prices call for a contract review. It is usually one or two of the five, not all of them.

A margin bridge shows this on one page: last year’s profit to this year’s, split into volume, price, mix, cost and overhead. If your finance team can produce it, you will know where to act. If it cannot, that is the first thing to build, and it is the core of good FP&A.

Start with a conversation

Find out where your margin is going.

Thirty minutes, no data request, no obligation. You leave with three priority gaps and what closing each is worth.